What Have I Been Doing…………..?
Gosh, another year where my intentions to increase my rate of posting have got away………..
Whilst work and home life have intruded, I have still managed to get some modelling done; including a rake of NER coaches for John James for which i do get something in return in due course.
The rake had a pair of three compartment thirds, of which this is an example:


All of the coaches were constructed from D&S kits on my Miscellany Models Fox bogies with replacement roofs formed of nickle silver sheet. I find that the plasticard offering in the D&S kits to be their weakest point. The problem with this is that if you make your own roofs i find you might as well also cut out the section below the clerestory – it makes a huge difference for the coach to be illuminated from above. The issue is, that there is a lot of work in these roofs – I found that for each there was 15+ hours of work just in the roof!


Also in the rake is an all third, which is probably my favourite of the build as it feels quite “pure” and also wihtout the problems of the composite…….see below…….



The rake only needed a modicum of first class accomodation made up from a composite diagram 7. Alas, this had a challenging problem that needed to be overcome, with the clerestory side pieces. These were much shallower than those on the other kits orwith the ends supplied in this kit. In addition to being obviously incorrect given the inconsistancy but the frames around the glazed lights were stunningly delicate. I regret persisting with this, i should have just drawn up some replacements in CAD and popped them in the next etching order.

However, i solved the problem by soldering a flat strip, 1.5*0.5mm along the base. in theory it should be to both the top and bottom but that was not realistically possible and I decided life was too short. After much fighting, cussing, fighting, screaming and more fighting, I did get it there, as I hope you can see.


I was asked to do these as gas lit coaches and therefore there is a bit going on below, as one might say.

As the coaches were quite long lived, they went through many detailed changes. for anyoen who is contemplating building some, I would heartily recommend reading David Addyman’s notes on how he built his in the Scaleforu Forum https://www.scalefour.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=39&t=7210&p=101662&hilit=ner+coaches#p101662 David’s coaches are modelled in the 1930s, so have different lighting arrangements, footsteps, bogie spring dampers and sides to the clerestories. Lots of things to be aware of if you are doing something similar.
At the end of this rather mammoth build, I had four coaches that i was rather proud of. They look rather fine on John Wright’s Benfieldside viaduct.

I am also pleased that i do not have to paint these; i am still looking for my lining mojo. I had it as a teenager, but have grown shy of lining. Maybe something for the Christmas break?
In the meantime, here are a couple of pictures of the newly restored NER coach 818 at Kirby Stephen, courtesy of the Beamish website. Does’t she look magnificant? I really must get up to see her.


Posted on December 22, 2024, in Benfieldside, Workbench (stock) and tagged clerestory, Coach, D&S, D&S Kit, David Addyman, EM, etching, Kirby Stephen, lner, Model Railway, ner, North Eastern Railway, p4, Scalefour Forum, Stainmore. Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.
Well! after looking through this email, I now have to wipe up the dribble. I have a puncheon for clerestories. You’v done a fantastic job on these, and they are gonna look stunning when painted. When they released the real one, my heart skipped a beat. it’s beautiful. But alas, way out of my region of modelling. ( LBSCR ) but I also model a bit of GWR, LSWR, SECR, GNR, LNWR. I do my clerestory roof pretty much the same way. I make mine removeable. I fit it and mark out where the clerestory is and cut out with a slitting disc, solder the sides on, then the clerestory roof. I find it quite easy that way. Now. Do you still supply the fox bogie etches ? as I will be needing some soon in the new year. Great work Sir. Happy Christmas and new year to you. Al.
Hi Alan and thanks for your comments.
As you say, the coach at Kirby Stephen is really fine and it is good that it seems to be so well appreciated up there.
It does sound as if we make our roofs in a similar manner and certainly mine (lower roof/clerestory sides and upper roof) are removable. It makes the painting a lot easier.
Yes, a new stock of Fox Bogies in recently, so drop us a line when you are ready (sorry, there will be a slight price increase as the etchers are not getting nay cheaper!).
Mark
Hi Mark,
lovely work on the NER clerestories. Having built a few of these and made brass roofs for the latest ones – I’m impressed by how you form the cut outs to allow light into the compartments. My fear would be distortion through the rollers? I used .5 mm brass which was far too thick. Next time I’ll order .3mm.
I have a luggage composite to build. Thanks for the ‘heads up’ on the clerestory problems!
best wishes,
David
Hi Mark,
Coaches look very good!
Although I would have commented on the coaches anyway, I would appreciate a response to the 2 mails I sent first on 10 Dec & then again on 21 Dec. I can send them again if you didn’t get them.
Wishing you a Merry Christmas & New Year!
William